Team A --------------- Team B good player --------------- good player average player -------------- average player good player --------------- bad player bad player -------------------- good player average player ------------------ average player average player -------------------- average player This is what you want. BUT....... Team A ------------------------- Tean B pro player ---------------------- Good player good palyer ------------------ Good player bad player --------------------- Good player bad player ----------------- Good player bad player ----------------------- Good player average player ----------------------- Good player THIS is what you get. The problem is that Bungies matchmaking sees these two examples as the same team balancing.