Two problems I see 1) not everyone has a sword (although this is kinda mute as I can't imagine why you would want to get one) 2) This one is more important, is the defending against other swords. I think that in order to stop 1 hit kills shields would need to be buffed a lot and your jump height + agility is increased. I would also tweak it for individual classes so Hunters have the highest agility buff Warlocks have the Highest Jump buff Titans have the highest Armour buff The last thing I would make is that when your super is charged it creates a jump and smash for non exotics, and for exotics it produces there normal super move so as a means to avoid this being spammed. Overall I am all for this, especially as I am a sword fighter (Fencing) so anything that is honorable combat suits me.