I've never liked it. I can appreciate it as a very well made game, but it just lacks impact for me. The combat felt "floaty" and didn't have a satisfying visceral thrill. Keep in mind I only ever played the original and 3 that I got with games with gold. And never played online multiplayer. So I probably didn't give it a fair shot, but if a game doesn't grab my attention after a few hours I tend to move to something else. My backlog of games is ridiculous and has been for s number of years. If I had an Xbone I'd probably get the collection just to see what the big deal is.