Honestly? I would still say no. Because I know there would still be people out there getting screwed over by it and there's no reason for it. The biggest problem I have with the proposed idea of allowing people to take a few forward with them, is if they can do a few then why not all? If there is no restrictions on which guns you can take forward, then technically speaking EVERY gun from Year 1 would potentially be brought forward regardless because everyone has different tastes. In other words, we would be seeing all of these older weapons in Year 2 regardless, so why not just remove that limit and make it that much simpler? The conflict itself is geared towards Bungie wanting to force us to leave Year 1 stuff behind. They don't want the old to still be relevant. We shouldn't be trying to cut a deal or negotiate this, but instead fight the MENTALITY itself that Year 1 shouldn't be allowed to continue onward.