Most people that dislike halo will be ps fanboys . It's the same thing with the xbox fanboys who say the last of us sucks the fact is neither of them do .... I am a ps4 player now PS3 before that but I owned the original Xbox and the 360 for about 5 years combined and completed halo 1-3 on several occasions and can honestly say it's one of the best fps ever made; sure some people may not like the genre but to say it's a bad game is just silly . TLOU is the same an amazing game definitely in my top 3 games ever made I don't really see where someone can find major problem with it ... I don't see the point in being a fanboy if a games good then it's good why argue otherwise just because it's on a different console from the one you use