Some of things I posted yesterday are a good start. There is no definition for how they calculated anything. Your first stat above states the percentages are the demographics in crucible across all platforms but the stats page does not say crucible anywhere. If the crucible stats are different than you stats then everyone one of your deductions may be wrong.

[quote]Some of things I posted yesterday are a good start. There is no definition for how they calculated anything.[/quote] Have you put in a request to Destiny Tracker? To me the stats are satisfying enough to conclude that Hunters aren't under-powered, and Titans aren't over-powered. [quote]Your first stat above states the percentages are the demographics in crucible across all platforms but the stats page does not say crucible anywhere. [i]If the crucible stats are different than you stats then everyone one of your deductions may be wrong.[/i][/quote] Different? They're constantly updated, so yes, they will be different. That does however not mean that the rest of the stats are invalid.

[quote]Different? They're constantly updated, so yes, they will be different. That does however not mean that the rest of the stats are invalid.[/quote] You are misinterpreting what I meant by "different". I don't mean that they change, I mean the actual definition of what's in the field is different. You claim that the percentages are PvP but the stats page just says "Class Breakdown", it does not state PvP only. I think that is just the overall breakdown of how many overall guardians there are of each class. For arguments sake, let's assume that the stat above is for PvE/PvP and PvP only stats actually look like this (based on games played as that class): Hunter - 40% Warlock -35% Titan - 25% With this assumption, some of your assertions would dramatically change because you are no longer assuming that the classes are close to equal in their base distribution. With this distribution, classes look OP in some areas and underpowered in others.

I very much doubt there are larger differences in the spread between PvE and PvP. But feel free to request stats from Destiny Tracker. I'm done here until you have something other than a hypothesis.