I give it 9/10. It has issues, it isn't flawless, but Bungie has already shown that they do plan to take an active role with it (even if some of the changes that they make aren't exactly fan favorites) and that they can fix the issues. The gameplay is awesome, the raids are tons of fun, it is addictive as all get out. I definitely got my money's worth. As for the Metacritic score, I don't put stock in that since anyone who's butthurt can go flood the ratings with 1/10 reviews. I looked at some of the Destiny reviews there at launch, and it was stuff like "1/10 for no offline play" or "1/10 because I dislike the voice chat." Those are valid complaints, but 1/10 for the whole game for them? No.