My hunter would have a claw from the fallen captain that almost killed him, a tooth from phogoth that he got from he ashes after the kill, a trinket he crafted from the gate lord he killed, a command key he took off of Valus after he was taken down, and finally the small piece of cloth he found from his own remains reminding him of the life he once had prior to becoming a guardian cursed to fight, die, be reassembled again and again day after day for as long as the light remains.