[quote]Congratz, you just proved that an all-powerful being cannot exist.[/quote] An all-powerful being doesn't need to be able to do "anything", just what matters and is relevant. A perfectly good being doesn't need to be able to be evil to be able to create something beautiful, or to do good. Nor does a being need to be able to accurately fulfill paradoxes to be more powerful than we are. Right?

I think your arguments can be dismantled as much as you did with mine, because the topic we are talking about steps beyond human logic. We are obviously limited, so our own thoughts cannot resolve or even describe it properly. I guess it's up to our personal sensibility. So, I think I can't say you're wrong! :)