I want to know the interwebs answer.
-
Was it a good idea to give it to 343? Probably not. I think that someone else should have done it but I think Bungie was done with halo. Halo 4 is a good example. If Bungie kept with halo it would eventually turn into that. I don't hate halo 4 as much most people do but compared top other halo games it falls short.