Ohhh that's a tough one. Thor has the charm and muscles but Anakin has his Jedi personality which can be charming for a girl. I would say Thor mainly because of his hammer and muscles. What would you say?

Well, both have charm in my eyes that girls like, but Anakin has anger and power issues. Thor has issues with showing off, but learns from his mistakes and doesn't seem to care for what he only wants but cares for others. Anakin puts what he wants most first it seems. Thor would be the better choice in my opinion, at least he's more human in terms of physical and mental states...at least from what is seen in the movies. haven't read and books or anything for either of them.