I have to say the first. The gun mechanics aren't all that great, but who needs them when you have Wrench Jockey 2, Frozen Field 2, and Bloodlust? Besides when you fight a big daddy. It's just such a massive throwback and I'm still amazed when the projector screen falls, Rapture is revealed, and Andrew Ryan says [i]"Rapture!"[/i]. I just do wish the guns were better. The way it goes, once you find the shotgun there's nothing better, especially since it has both shock rounds and incendiary rounds. Though the chemical thrower is pretty great when fully upgraded, well the Electric gel that is. The game just makes the Electric damage better than most. Hell, I found myself using anything with electricity the most on the Hardest Difficulty, the one-two punch combo is just great.