A flat tax rate in terms of percentage of income would [i]theoretically[/i] be the fairest option. Unfortunately, theory and reality are often different.
In reality, a progressive tax is more "fair" because corporations and high net worth individuals often cannot act honestly - they use loopholes available in the system to avoid being taxed on money that they "hide". The simplest example of this is corporations hiding income in offshore accounts to avoid taxation on that income.
People like to chop it down to "hatred" or "jealousy" for wealthy people. That's not the case. Wealthy people try their hardest to avoid taxes and often end up not paying their fair share of taxes.
That aside, taxing the poor more is obviously not going to do anything but make their lives harder. However, taxing the wealthy at higher rates does have some arguments. One argument is that nobody actually [i]needs[/i] millions or billions of dollars that they just sit on without investing back into the economy, and therefore taxing at higher rates is beneficial to society as a whole. A lot of people don't like this idea and see it as "stealing" from people who "work harder" (often not the case, but that is a separate topic).
To take everything into perspective, take this fact and think about: 62 people in the world hold more wealth altogether than the poorest 3,600,000,000 people. People will argue that they earned their wealth, though that is often not the case. The Walton family for instance did nothing but inherit, as one example.
English
-
The only problem with your theory is that taxing the rich more will just make them leave and take their jobs with them. This is already a major problem in why we've lost so many jobs and why so many companies have left the US. We already have the highest corporate tax in the world. Progressive tax would make it worse. Flat tax is fair and I think most business owners would get behind it.
-
Where are they gonna go? Would it be a bad thing if they left? Couldn't we have more start up businesses this way?
-
Edited by OdinsDaDdy: 1/28/2016 1:34:46 PMThey go to places like China and Mexico. With the loss of jobs and the labor participation rate lower than ever you'd think that would be a boon for small business. But when your government regulates small business to death it becomes nearly impossible for them to make it. So you tell me. Why aren't small businesses thriving already?
-
Because we don't shop there with the fear of spending an extra $10. We've done this to ourselves.
-
Taxing the rich heavily would just make them look for even more loopholes. Look at all the corporations moving their factories to different countries.
-
It's also because of cheap labor and free trade agreements