Both of you are wrong, why? The CHANCE that a higher light lvl player has done the raid more often is higher as someone who is a of a lower light lvl. Like you said. Same enemies with same attacks. So one that has been more often in the raid is more experienced with these attacks and does know where to stand. So i have to slightly agree with opp. Light lvl is not skill based but experienced based (mostly, or you got some pretty good loot in the few raids you ran). Opp is saying skilled players, yet he means experienced raiders. You want to challange him in a crucible game. But pve isnt pvp. A good pvp player can suck at a raid because he doesnt know where to stand and what to do. Those 2 things are entirely different. Im not good at pvp but are skilled at pve. Why? Because pve is all about repeating the same thing over again and im good at that thing. Pvp is to adapt to other players and not cpu. A whole lot harder, but opp wants good pve players. Not pvp.