I don't think this new one is bad, but I think Nolan might have chose the wrong tone for the ghost. He should have gone with a voice more similar to his Desmond Miles, so the transition from Dinklebot would be smoother. I do like the new ghost a bit, but I didn't have any problems with the Dinklebot at all. I will admit though, the new ghost does sort of make me think of an old kid's cartoon whenever a guardian dies out in the wild.