Your forgetting one thing. It's not FTL, the slip space cuts in and out of reality, and MACs don't have to penetrate. Use the -blam!-ing ship. It was a tactic used by the infinity vs the covies with good effect. Also their shields are calibrated for lasers not physical projectiles. It's show they can only defend against one type of attack at a time.
English
-
Yea no star destroyers shields are for blocking debris and small to medium asteroids and lasers (any asteroid due to cosmic speeds+ mass is roughly 500x more powerful than a NUKE of the same yield) yea hyperspace and slipspace are different but BOTH are FTL and star destroyers are faster. As for ground war ild love to see afew ODST teams get PWN3D by a legion of troopers and 4x AT AT (the battleforce aboard 1x star destroyer) and star destroyers ARE DESIGNED to sterilize the surface of a planet till its devoid of all life (just 1x btw)
-
So are covenant troop ships. We are thinking of humanity and covies as one army. The shields is an interesting point, but both human and alien forces have used EMPs alongside some of their salvos. Also, ODSTs are deployed in the hundreds for assaults and are trained to be guerrilla fighters. A single soldier with a grenade, cutter and grappling hook had no problem taking down an AT-AT and neither should an ODST with satchel charges energy blades and magnetic gear. Your also forgetting the SPARTANs and normal Marines to add as force multipliers.
-
Your also forgetting they have to get thru nearly 2000 trained troops/galactic marines with blasters, heavy blasters, blaster turrets, snipers, shock troops with rockets, and each storm troop has a grenade charge that's double the yield of a thermal detonator, an they gotta chew through that before they get to the at at.
-
Or drop an HEV pod right on top of it. You're forgetting how ODSTs get to planets. They're bloody missiles. And it would be the marines that would have to get through it. And the clones aren't a threat, they can't hit shit.
-
Missles can be intercepted; Theyre called lasers. Clones hit plenty, the storm troopers are only inaccurate in the old movies; they hit plenty in everything else. As far as droppin drop pods on top of targets, yea that'll do dmg, soon as they land tho they are sitting ducks for the second wave of troops or the heavy artillery in the back.
-
If its FASTER THAN LIGHT its ftl: http://www.fatwallet.com/blog/fastest-ship-in-the-universe/
-
Yes that type of travel is FTL travel but not the same kind a star destroyer uses. And what about my other points? Can you top those?