I'm on PS4, but in your shoes I'd definitely go with the Xbox One. All your progress carries over. You get a more reliable network. The PS4 controller experiences so much wear and tear, and has a 6hr battery life compared to the Xbox One controller's ~50hr battery life. Yes, the PS4 is a bit more powerful, and has destiny exclusives. But the PS4 doesn't have many other exclusives currently. Like with the last gen consoles, Sony will take 2 or 3 years to really hit their stride.