I've never had a PS3-4 But my Xbox is the worst Xbox I've owned, bad/loose hdmi port, no hd space, have to quit apps and constantly restart them. Never connects properly and when you go to diagnose an issue, it just sits and loads for forever. The party system still doesn't work properly. It's impossible to send invites for anything without navigating 300 menus. Not to mention it's so slow in what it does do. They made everything so hard to do when the 360 was so easy If my friends had a play station I'd proboly have that