Mine is actually base Dark Souls II. (though SotFS would probably beat it, if I had a One to play it..) I've unfortunately never played DeS, Bloodborne or King's Field, though, so it's only between DaS I & II. Now, reasons DaS II wins; I like Humanity (and its mechanics) better than Human Effigies The bonfire appearance in the first one better Hollows' appearance in the first one And the covenants better in the first one But DaS II wins because of the room it leaves for theories to link back to the first DaS. (SotFS ruined a lot of mine, I think, though..) Well that, and all the NPCs didn't Hollow. ._.