JavaScript is required to use Bungie.net

Clan Recruitment - Destiny 2

Look for Clans or seek new members.

This thread is inspired by another: view original post

Edited by MrMoose007: 11/18/2026 6:06:07 PM
1

Prophets of the IX – Former Member Review

Former Member Review [b]Overall rating: 4/10[/b] Prophets of the IX is a very active clan with a generally welcoming atmosphere. My experience with the regular members was mostly positive, and I met some genuinely great people here. There are plenty of opportunities to play, and finding people online generally isn't an issue. Unfortunately, the organizational and administrative side of the community left a lot to be desired. [b]The positives:[/b] - Very welcoming initially. - Highly active Discord and in-game community. - Generally respectful and enjoyable clan members. - Plenty of opportunities to participate in activities. [b]The negatives:[/b] - Little meaningful vetting of new members. - Poor organization of endgame LFG groups by experience and skill level. - Official Sherpa events could be considerably better organized. - Unofficial Sherpa runs are often excellent, but there's little transparency around Sherpa qualifications. - Administrative interactions are excessively formal, enforcement-oriented, and, in my experience, unnecessarily intimidating. My biggest concern is the administrative culture. After leaving the in-game clan and establishing a small clan with my wife, I explicitly agreed not to recruit or advertise within Prophets. Despite that, discussions with administration repeatedly involved warnings of permanent bans, references to responding with an "iron fist," and eventually "-blam!- around and find out." I raised my concerns through the server's advertised complaints process, which promises fairness, accountability, and protection against retaliation. Following an administrative review and vote, both my wife and I were removed. They told me I hadn't violated any rules, but were removing me regardless because: [quote] we feel you are not having the best experience and time within our server, and we are concerned further participation from you might take a toll on you and your view on Destiny as a whole.[/quote] -SilentRift#7876 [i]Second Clan Founder: Prophets of the IX[/i] They removed my wife under rule #9 against deliberately creating drama or hostility, to "safeguard our members" from "potential" issues. I can't establish that our removal was retaliation for submitting a complaint, but the circumstances left me seriously questioning how the administration applies its own published standards, especially since the only actual rule they mentioned in their reasoning for banning me was rule #9, which they admit that neither my wife, nor I, actually violated. [b]Screenshots:[/b] You can read the administrative conversations, published policies, investigation timeline, and removal decision yourself at the link above or right here: [url]https://imgur.com/a/oaBJi2u[/url] [b]Final thoughts[/b] The members are generally good people, and the clan is certainly active. However, I would encourage prospective members to pay attention to how administration handles disagreements, not just how welcoming the community is when they first join. My experience ultimately convinced me that it wasn't the right community for me or my wife. If you are considering joining this clan, or have already joined, I would highly reccomend avoiding the admin wherever possible. Stay away from participation in their formal events, and stick to the unofficial member-organized events. If you happen to run into trouble during your time here, I do not reccommend asking the admin for help. I can't reccomend using their advertised help ticket feature, as I don't believe they actually uphold themselves to the standards they promise to as leaders. They declare that they are a safe space to voice concerns, but my experience with them has lead me to think otherwise. Criteria ratings These ratings reflect my personal experience, not an objective measurement of every member's experience. Ratings Initial welcome 8/10 Community activity 9/10 General member conduct 8/10 New-member vetting 4/10 Endgame LFG organization 4/10 Official Sherpa program 3/10 Unofficial Sherpa opportunities 7/10 Administrative communication 2/10 Administrative transparency 2/10 Fairness and consistency of enforcement 2/10 Overall experience 4/10 The overall rating is my subjective assessment of the experience as a whole, with particular weight given to the administrative issues described above. It is not the average of the category scores. I wrote a more detailed account of my experience, including the background, administrative communications, complaint process, final decision, and supporting screenshots. If you're considering joining Prophets of the IX and want more context behind my review, you can read it here: [b]Full review with details here:[/b] [url]https://docs.google.com/document/d/1jIhUrleMAS5Ym9Par9xNZoYmUKdpZzHwx8xQVmTCRk0/edit?usp=sharing[/url]
English
#Clans

Posting in language:

 

Play nice. Take a minute to review our Code of Conduct before submitting your post. Cancel Edit Create Fireteam Post

  • MrMoose, I appreciate you sharing your concerns, and I'm not dismissing your experience. However, your removal wasn't about having an opinion or raising concerns. It was about a repeated pattern of escalating minor disagreements and inconveniences into larger issues requiring admin intervention. Rules and admin responsibilities exist to protect the community, not to enforce one person's personal views or expectations. A healthy community needs room for differing opinions, respectful debate and compromise. Not every disagreement needs to become a moderation issue, nor should things have to be done one person's way. Ultimately, the decision to remove you was made with the wider community in mind. As admins, our responsibility is to ensure everyone feels welcome and can enjoy the game without being caught up in repeated conflicts or unnecessary tension. This decision wasn't taken lightly, but we have to prioritise the health and enjoyment of the community as a whole. Should forum administration request further information, we are more than happy to provide the entirety of the conversation and relevant context, rather than selective excerpts that may present an incomplete or misleading picture. This will be the only response you receive from us on this matter. Any further negative posts or attempts to continue this discussion on our forum thread will be reported to administration for review. We genuinely wish you and your wife all the best in your next chapter of Destiny 2. Take care, and good luck with whatever adventures come next. Signed SilentRift#7876 Second Clan Founder, Prophets of the IX

    Posting in language:

     

    Play nice. Take a minute to review our Code of Conduct before submitting your post. Cancel Edit Create Fireteam Post

You are not allowed to view this content.
;
preload icon
preload icon
preload icon