JavaScript is required to use Bungie.net

Destiny 2

Discuss all things Destiny 2.
5/28/2026 1:48:40 PM
4

Are the Nine greater than the Witness.

So, I’ve been seeing discussion about the Winnower, the Witness, and the Nine, and it’s made me think about something. Circa back to Edge of Fate, and it’s revealed that the Guardian, unlike Ikora or Lodi needed no intervention in order for the Guardian to become the Weapon of the Nine. Although, the Guardian did need intervention from the Traveler through Elsie Bray in order so we wouldn’t fall to the Darkness. This means that a good chunk of the events that happen within the Light and Dark saga would still have happened in the manner they had, albeit some of these events were taken advantage of in order to push certain people toward certain outcomes, like the Nine hiding the presence of the Red Legion in order for one of them to attempt an escape (iirc) and to ensure Orins ghost was killed so that she’d become the Emissary. It’s was twofold. I doubt we would have fended off the Cabal from caging the Traveler and that the Traveler would have woken up anyways, without the intervention of the Nine. The fact that we could get onto the Flagship to assassinate Ghaul was lucky in itself. So, with the understanding that the Nine didn’t really manipulate the events of the Light and Dark saga besides setting up a couple of pieces in order to ensure that should we succeed, we’d either be the tool for their freedom or for their binding, how then does the Witness compare in strength to the Nine. I feel it’s a pretty close match in spite of the Nine being 4th dimensional beings. The Witness is of lesser strength than the Traveler and Veil, as we only defeated the Witness with the assistance of the Traveler. And below the Traveler, there are the Echos, one of which was strong enough to kill III of the Nine. So I’d say that the Traveler is of greater power than the Nine. But if that’s the case, are the Nine greater than the Witness. That, and how would the Traveler/Veil interact with the Nine. If the Nine control the laws by which Paracausality can manifest, then would that mean that the Nine could kill the Traveler? Would Nightfall Station be capable of it. Nightfall Station was meant to target the Last City, not the Traveler. To destroy the immortal guardians who rule over the Last City in an immortal Militacrocy. But we see in the cutscene that the Nightfall Station would pierce the Traveler though this cutscene only had the Traveler above the last city. Also, as an aside, do the average people know about Neomuna, or is it just the Guardians and Vanguard? Cause, like, it would be pretty funny if Dredgen Bale didn’t know about Neomuna.
English
#lore #destiny2

Posting in language:

 

Play nice. Take a minute to review our Code of Conduct before submitting your post. Cancel Edit Create Fireteam Post

  • Everything in the game is a manipulation from the Nine, whether totally intentional or not. The Nine are beyond paracausality. You are trying to compare a pon (The Witness) to a general rule of paracausal existence (The Nine). The Nine are rules of the flower game between the Winnower and Gardener. The Winnower and Gardener play the game, the Nine bend it to reality, the chess pieces (Guardians, Traveler, The Witness, the Worms, Taken, Hive, Eliksni) get moved according to the [i]input player[/i] in accordance with the [i]rules[/i]. Destiny is a game where you do cool things, fight aliens and save humanity... ...when in actuality your Guardian's [b]Destiny[/b] is being a cog-in-the-machine of a game being played by outside entities who see you as but a tiny chess piece.

    Posting in language:

     

    Play nice. Take a minute to review our Code of Conduct before submitting your post. Cancel Edit Create Fireteam Post

  • I think the Witness, cause thing with paracausality raw power is rather meaningless in a fight. That’s how we slayed gods as a baby guardian while legendary ones died. That said, I don’t see the Nine having fighting powers. Given their nature and physicality, they likely can’t. Meanwhile the Witness is the ultimate master of Darkness and has a list of offensive abilities both physically and consciously. So the only thing they could do is time manipulate a puppet to fight for them and in most instances that would mean easy Witness victory. They didn’t dive deep enough into their new role as masters of paracausality for us to know how or if that can be used to stop him directly.

    Posting in language:

     

    Play nice. Take a minute to review our Code of Conduct before submitting your post. Cancel Edit Create Fireteam Post

  • Is Neomuna stationary or does it just constantly fly around the planet? I thought it was stationary, but it has those big propellers in the back so now I'm not sure.

    Posting in language:

     

    Play nice. Take a minute to review our Code of Conduct before submitting your post. Cancel Edit Create Fireteam Post

    1 Reply
    • Yes the nine can manipulate events to their design and see future possibilities with clarity. The witness is just a entity made up of many minds many of which seek freedom essentially making the witness just 1 person afraid to lose power but consumed by its own ego. The witness is playing 2D chess it's playing by the limitations of the game while the nine are playing 6D chess they can move pieces however the need to alter the outcome to a desired one. If the witness took a shot at the nine it sure could kill one or two but the nine would move a piece or pieces into place to stop it going to far.

      Posting in language:

       

      Play nice. Take a minute to review our Code of Conduct before submitting your post. Cancel Edit Create Fireteam Post

    You are not allowed to view this content.
    ;
    preload icon
    preload icon
    preload icon