JavaScript is required to use Bungie.net

OffTopic

Surf a Flood of random discussion.
1/1/2026 11:10:27 PM
3

So, I've been watching MORE Doctor Who (Tennant)

Good evening everybody! This is Aifos coming to you alive from that blue box sitting on the corner of the road! Yes, the same one as last time, and no I have not left this spot! It is very cold outside, please bring me a blanket. I'd go get one myself, but then the blue box might disappear on me, and I won't let that happen! So, as you may know, a little while ago I started watching Doctor Who for the first time. My previous post was made after I had finished Eccleston, and now I have just finished Tennant. Which, first and foremost, an update from last time, I have found both the Whittaker collection, and the 60th anniversary specials, so I shall watch those as well. The newest Doctor is still off limits. And I have to say, I'm very glad to be watching this show. I've loved every single episode! Well, all of them but one. Well, more like three or four, but only three or four! But really, I've quite enjoyed the characters, and the world, and the story arcs big and small. I will be very impressed if Tennant ends up not being my favorite Doctor because I really like Tennant. His personality is pretty similar to Eccleston, but with a few extra quirks that I just really enjoy. You can probably already guess what my favorite one is just by reading this post. While I still hold that Rose & the Doctor's relationship would've been more fun with a father/daughter dynamic, Rose being the person the Doctor was in love with felt less off with Tennant. I don't really have an explanation as for why, more just the vibe I got. Maybe it was the way they talked, or maybe I had just accepted it by then so my brain pushed back a bit less. I was a little iffy about the parallel world stuff at first, but I really came around to it by the time the season finale came around. I think Season 2's finale is probably my favorite of the bunch, but more on that below. My favorite moment for Rose probably has to be the end of Season 2 where she refuses to leave the Doctor. A boring answer, probably, but it was very good, what can I say? Rose and the Doctor really did care for each other a lot, and it was nice to see how far she'd go to stay with him. Martha was probably my favorite of the Doctor's companions. She felt a lot more active, I suppose. Like it felt like there were a lot more situations where Martha was on her own separated from the Doctor and had to figure things out, where Rose was a lot more along for the ride. I also thought her family dynamic was really fun, though I feel like we didn't get to see them as much as the others... But, that may just because there were more people to keep track of. She also probably gets bonus points for being in the Family of Blood episodes. If I have to pick from Season 3, my favorite moment from Martha is probably somewhere in the Family of Blood, but to be honest, my favorite scene with her probably comes from Season 4, and it's not actually a scene we see. In Turn Left, though, we hear she gave the last of the oxygen to one of her coworkers to save them during the the whole Smith & Jones thing, dying as a result. I may be a little biased by that scene being in Turn Left, though... Still, very touching. Martha, like the Doctor, would let herself die to save others without a second thought, and I like that trait in both of them. While Martha was probably my favorite companion, though, Donna definitely had my favorite dynamic with the Doctor. She was the only one who didn't have a romance subplot with the Doctor going on which I really appreciated. I didn't really care for all that with the other two companions, and I liked that Donna was, in the Doctor's own words, his best friend. Plus, Donna had a lot more funny lines, like "Oh, it doesn't work on WOOD?!". Good fun. My favorite scene with Donna is also in Turn Left, because I really love Turn Left, and it's when she's talking with her mother. Donna says something along the lines of "Guess I've always been a disappointment, huh?" and her mum says "Guess so.". Like, aww, poor Donna! My heart! The bit where the Doctor was traveling on his own was quite heartbreaking. Seeing him purposefully distance himself from everyone was very sad, especially when we get the Waters of Mars and see him absolutely lose it. He admitted to Donna at the beginning of the season that he needed someone to help him know when to stop, and when we actually see that play out it was so very sad. My favorite bit of the Doctor, as Tennant, is tricky, but it's either when he sat with the Ood in their cell, and how Donna could only listen to their song for a few seconds and when she asks the Doctor if he can still hear it he says "Always.", or it's in the finale where he turns to the Master and says "Get out of the way." followed by the Master doing the same thing to him. Like, he got the *Master* of all people to save his life. The other contender is also in the finale, right at the very end when he goes and visits everyone before he dies. Much sad. There may be a little bit of bias there, though because I watched the finale literally yesterday. Overall, though, wonderful show. I love it, and I'm excited to keep going. But okay, let's talk about specific episodes now! This post will run out of room, so that's in the selected answer below.

Posting in language:

 

Play nice. Take a minute to review our Code of Conduct before submitting your post. Cancel Edit Create Fireteam Post

  • Let's start off with the episodes I didn't like so I can talk about the good ones after. Like: New Earth [spoiler]New Earth was one of the few episodes I'd seen before starting this run of the show, so that could have something to do with it. I already sort of new the plot twist. But I think it was more than that. Cassandra felt really out of place, and the episode just didn't feel like it was taking itself as seriously as many of the other episodes did. Felt like it was kinda just one [b]B[/b]ig gag, mainly due to Cassandra. Plus, I don't really buy the solution. Mixing all the medicines together most likely would not work to cure all the diseases, especially not on the entire population of diseased humans. I don't know, it was just weird. And as Tennant's second episode, it had me a bit worried, but thankfully it was the odd one out![/spoiler] Voyage of the Damned [spoiler]Voyage of the Damned was... Well... For one, this was supposedly one of the episodes taking place in the modern day, yet despite this the sp[b]A[/b]ceship was full of people who looked very human. Now, Time Lords and humans also look basically the same, so that's probably the explanation for what this was, just another human like alien race, but I don't know, I don't really buy it. The Hosts just also were not very scary compared to many of the other spooky monsters we'd seen. The pacing also just felt really off. They needed to establish that cyborgs were hated in this society, which itself is fine, that could lead to some interesting questions, but we were informed of this through some very iffy exposition. And it's all capped off by a very goofy climax that's very difficult to take seriously. By far my least favorite episode.[/spoiler] The Unicorn and the Wasp [spoiler]I kinda dislike this one for being exactly what it wante[b]D[/b] to be. Like, both lorewise and conceptually it's supposed to feel sort of like a discount Agatha Christie novel... But, uh, "discount Agatha Christie novel" isn't a great sell. The "And Then There Were None we have at home, and also there's a giant bee". Very meh. Plus, I don't buy the idea that Agatha is the one who puts together everything but the alien stuff. Being able to write a murder mystery is one thing, but being able to solve one? That's an entirely different skillset. And Then There Were None is a great book, though. You should read it.[/spoiler] Brief mention to the The Impossible Planet/Satan Pit, and The Runaway Bride. I didn't hate them, but they were... Fine. Kinda meh. But okay, let's get on to my favorites! Army of Ghosts/Doomsday [spoiler]Probably my favorite season finale. I love how it really just pulled everything together. The alternate dimension stuff, the Cybermen, Torch[b]W[/b]ood... Then, we get that whole Genesis Arc thing, and I was scratching my brain the whole time to figure out what "Time Lord Science" could mean. Then they reveal that it's bigger on the inside and I was just like "Whaaat! No way, it was staring me in the face the whole time! I love it!" Rose getting her dad back (sort of) did feel like it went against the theme of Father's Day a little bit, but that it came at the cost of losing the Doctor kinda made up for... That... Wait a minute... Still, good fun, and it introduce the Cult of Skaro, who I ended up really liking. I don't think I'll be mentioning them on this list of my favorite episodes, so I'll just briefly mention that I really like the idea of how when you give Daleks the imagination to think for themselves, they seem to turn against the rest of the Daleks in disgust of what their kind has done. Happened twice. Good fun.[/spoiler] Gridlock [spoiler]I got a soft spot for episodes where the big scary thing isn't actually the monster, and Gridlock was one of those. There was a big scary m[b]O[/b]nster, sure, but that wasn't really the central conflict here. The big thing you're supposed to look at and say "Omigosh that's awful..." is just the state of the world. How people live their entire lives in their cars. Which, like, yeah, that is kinda awful. The twist of how it turned out to not be a corrupt government, but a government that managed to save the poor people as they were dying was fun, too. I genuinely did not see it coming. I really enjoyed it. This episode redeems New Earth.[/spoiler] Human Nature/Family of Blood [spoiler]There's a fun trope you don't see too often, where someone on the hero team is, like, super big and overpowered, but then for whatever reason they're taken out of the picture, and suddenly even minor threats become super threatening. That is what is going on here. Like, the Family itself is not that scary. They're basically just people with guns. But since the Doctor isn't here, they become super threatening. It was also just kind heartbreaking to see the Doctor acting in ways he normally wou[b]L[/b]dn't. Approving of his students beating each other, being casually racist towards Martha... Like, Doctor, no! Then, of course, we get so many good lines at the end. John Smith grappling with the idea that Martha is there to kill him, Brother of Mine realizing that the Doctor was only fleeing from them to spare their lives, and of course probably the best one: "If the Doctor hadn't come here, on a whim, would anyone here have died?" Brilliant.[/spoiler] Midnight [spoiler]I don't think I have too much to say about Midnight, but I did really love it. Another one of those episodes where the monster isn't the scary part. It was kind of interesting to see a situation that the Doctor really couldn't get out of. This time, he only got out of it because of what someone else did, not himself. I like the little bit at the end where the Doctor asks for the hostess' name, too.[/spoiler] Turn Left [spoiler]This is my favorite episode. Omigosh, my poor heart! Showing us how bad things would have gotten had the Doctor not been there over and over to save the day. Martha gets killed, London explodes, and then we get those scenes were Donna is crammed in that little house with all those other people. The way her mother was broken, the way *she* was broken. The scene that probably hit me the hardest was when her neighbor was getting sent o[b]F[/b]f to a Labor Camp, and he was still smiling and laughing, trying to ease Donna's heart so she wouldnt worry about him, and she only realized what a "Labor Camp" was when her grandpa started freaking out. Pretty sure I was crying at that point. Fantastic episode, broke my heart.[/spoiler] There were many episodes that I did like, but those were my favorites, and I don't know how many more I could talk about without running out of room. But some of the runner ups would be: The Idiot's Lantern, Planet of the Ood, and Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead. But that's all for now folks, jambuhbye!

    Posting in language:

     

    Play nice. Take a minute to review our Code of Conduct before submitting your post. Cancel Edit Create Fireteam Post

  • Glad you didn’t cite Love & Monsters as one of your least favourite. Whilst I think the flak it gets for being kinda naff is justified, there is actually an interesting episode in there that people always miss beyond the protagonist’s girlfriend being turned into a paving slab.

    Posting in language:

     

    Play nice. Take a minute to review our Code of Conduct before submitting your post. Cancel Edit Create Fireteam Post

  • It's actually kinda crazy just how similar our views on the Tenant era are. Only difference being I actually liked Runaway Bride because of the Doctor/Donna dynamic and seeing a bit of that dark side of The Doctor. And yes Martha is the absolute G.O.A.T of the Doctor Companions. Easily the most capable and cares about others just as much as the Doctor if not more. I wish we got more of her. Midnight and Water on Mars are probably my Top Two. But the writing on Midnight is really such a tight script.

    Posting in language:

     

    Play nice. Take a minute to review our Code of Conduct before submitting your post. Cancel Edit Create Fireteam Post

    1 Reply
    You are not allowed to view this content.
    ;
    preload icon
    preload icon
    preload icon